After a decade in different banking careers, I’ve heard many stories from older clients that lived through a long forgotten time of high inflation and high interest rates in Canada. Everyone seems to remember a story of someone that could not afford their mortgage payments, which resulted in them leaving their keys under the doormat so that the bank could collect on the debt. I haven’t actually heard from anyone that experienced this first-hand though. This may be like one of those tales that people heard a few times and it instilled such fear that it eventually became a memory in their own minds (one of those, “it happened to a friend of a friend” moments). Don’t get me wrong, I do think that some people lost their homes due to foreclosure but I believe that there may have been other, extraneous circumstances that assisted in causing it, aside from just high inflation and interest rates. Maybe someone might have lost their job or went through a marital separation and it was just an unfortunate perfect storm of variables that caused them to be unable to afford their debt load. Foreclosures happen every year, regardless of where inflation and interest rates are, but it is only a very small percentage of homes that are actually foreclosed on.
We are currently experiencing another high inflationary environment and most developed economies around the world are talking about increasing rates soon (if they haven’t started already). Let’s not forget that we are coming off of historic lows on both inflation and interest rates so when I say a “high inflationary environment,” it is in context to where we were in January 2021 (0.72%). The long term average inflation rate since 1970 is 3.95% and, as of January 2022, we are sitting at an inflation rate of 4.8%. I’ve read enough articles and opinions on the internet that suggest we are headed towards a Canadian housing market calamity due to our current environment so I wanted to try to actually test these theories based on historical data.
I could not find any historical Canadian foreclosure data but pricing pressures are fairly easy to understand. An excess supply of a good in any market should decrease the cost of said good. If foreclosures were as rampant as people suggest they were during the 1970’s and 1980’s then we should be able to see the excess supply in the Canadian market by decreases in residential housing prices during those years.
I found some data sets that provide the Bank Of Canada Overnight Lending Rate, Canada’s Annual Inflation Rate, and the Residential Price Index in Canada from January 1970 to January 2022 (or 52 years). The annual Canadian Residential Price Index has fallen only 6 times over the course of 52 years (or around 12% of the time). One instance occurred in the 80’s and it was a drop of -1.1% in 1984. The majority of the other price decreases came during the 90’s (1990, 1991, 1995, 1996, 1998) and were -2.9%, -0.9%, -3.9%, -2.6%, and -0.3% respectively. These drops were the result of a Canadian economic recession, which spanned from 1990-1991. The recession was said to have been caused by restrictive monetary policy by central bankers (as they did not want inflation to get back to late 1970’s and 1980’s levels) and the loss of consumer/business confidence due to the oil price spike from the Gulf War. The fact is, that during the course of the decade, the average price of housing still increased by 3.4% through the 1990’s. An investment in housing, just like an investment in the equity markets, should be looked at as a long-term investment. Anyone trying to predict the market and make out with a quick buck should also be aware that the predictive nature of any market decreases almost entirely when you look at short periods of time.

The largest annual average price decrease in Canadian real estate was -5.6% in 2009. This was during The Great Financial Crisis, caused by cheap credit and lax lending standards in the USA, and worldwide housing was put under a microscope during this period of time. This was the worst financial crisis since The Great Depression but Canadian real estate remained relatively unscathed due to its stringent and highly regulated banking system. We had no bank failures, no bailouts, and our recession was less severe than the United States. Canadian banks remained profitable, continued to pay dividends, and continued to lend.
Over the 52 years from 1970 to 2022, the average Canadian price of real estate has grown by 2,950% (or an average compound return of about 9% per year). It has allowed Canadians access to another wealth creation strategy and to diversify from solely relying on worldwide equity markets. Our southern neighbors have had about half of our average price appreciation, the US House Price Index has only increased by a total of 800% from 1975 to 2022 (compared to Canada’s 1,515% over that same time period).
Don’t get me wrong, I completely understand why people believe the underlying financial principle that high inflation should lead to higher interest rates (as this is usually the Bank of Canada’s first arrow in their quiver to calm periods of higher inflation). Higher interest rates should decrease the value of the real estate. This is what financial principles tell us but the real world rarely cares about what you learned in Economics 101. I’ve put together a chart that shows multiple periods when Canadian interest rates were increasing and what was the effect on the Canadian Real Estate Price Index. I’ve also added in the inflation rates at the beginning and end of each period as well. During the nine increasing rate environments shown below, only one period of time (1994-1995) resulted in a decrease in the average price of Canadian real estate (-4%) and I’d argue that it had more to do with the overall Canadian economy trying to bounce back from a recession than the actual interest rate increases.

I believe that our problem stems from an equally simple principle from Economics 101, supply vs. demand. I put together a chart that shows the population growth of Canadians, over the age of 20, compared to the number of total housing starts per year. Our population over the age of 20 has grown from 13.3 million in 1971 to 30.2 million in 2021 but housing starts have remained very close to the average of 33,000 other than last year, where it hit an all time high of 59,000. There isn’t enough total units available for Canada’s population of potential home owners. The quoted data from housing starts includes single-detached, multiple family, semi-detached, row, apartment and other unit types. It is my opinion that we have a long road to go before the under-supply is corrected. The first step is to continue to achieve a higher annual growth rate of housing starts than the rate at which our population is growing. This can be a problem as home builders can get spooked easily and will build far less when the economy stumbles at all so only time will tell if they have learned from the errors of the past.

Going back to the title of this article, will high inflation lead to a real estate crash? I don’t believe it will. One thing that we have learned during the pandemic is that the modern government’s fiscal and monetary policies are much more accommodating than the restrictive policies of the 90’s era. We may see a period of time that the growth rate on the price of housing slows but I believe that this would be healthy for the overall market. There will be some years in the future that we experience price decreases too but that shouldn’t scare you, we have seen the average price of real estate fall 11% of the time from 1970 to 2022. All healthy markets should experience periodic years of negative returns and historical evidence has shown us that the health of the overall economy has far greater ramifications for the average price of real estate than the level of inflation or interest rates.
Home ownership isn’t a short-term transaction, it is something that is meant to be bought and held for very long periods of time. Like any market, I believe that trying to time your purchase for a potential future price fall is foolhardy. If the past has taught us anything, it is that growth should be expected over the long run and waiting on the sidelines may end up being more detrimental to your purchasing power than the actual drop in price (whenever it may occur).
Want to chat more? Email me at info@financerx.ca
Sources :
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/QCAN628BIS
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/USSTHPI
https://wowa.ca/bank-of-canada-interest-rate
https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/CAN/canada/inflation-rate-cpi
https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1710000501










